Thursday, February 23, 2012

Product Testing: Foundation Primers

So, a few months ago, I was shopping at Sephora, looking for some concealer, when I decided to do one of their mini-makeovers. The makeup artist started off by using a foundation primer- a product I was completely unfamiliar with. Turns out, if you're looking for your makeup to look flawless, and stay all day, then foundation primers are key! Essentially like a paint primer, the foundation primer smooths out your skin and creates a base for your makeup. Sounds pretty good, no? The makeover looked really nice, and I decided to pick up the Smashbox Photo Finish Foundation Primer. Then a little while ago, I received the Benefit Porefessional in my Birchbox, and so I decided it might be interesting to compare the two.

Smell: Neither one really has a smell to it

Texture: The Smashbox primer is a clear liquid. It feels a little tacky on your fingers, but goes on your face very easily. I was told to wait a minute or two after I put it on my face before I put on my foundation, so I do that with both primers. The Benefit primer is lightly tinted, although I'm not sure the tint really does much, at least not for my skin tone. It feels powdery, and almost feels like you've brushed mineral powder or pressed powder on your face.

Results: Honestly, I can't tell the difference between the two.

Price: The Smashbox product comes in a to-go version (0.5 oz) that ranges from $16-$17 and a full size version (1 oz) that's between $36-$42. The Benefit product is $29 for 0.75oz. There really isn't much different in the price per oz. Please note that all these prices are from Sephora. 

Animal Testing Policy: Smashbox explicitly states on their packaging that they do not test on animals. On their website, they go on to further state that they do not ask other to test on their behalf, except where required by law. Benefit does not state that on their packaging, but provides more information on their animal testing on their website. And no, they don't test on animals either although they cannot make the same claim for the raw materials used in the products.

My preference: At the end of the day, I personally prefer the Smashbox primer for two reasons: (1) It comes in a small enough package that I can slip into my purse-makeup bag, and (2) I prefer the texture over the somewhat powdery feeling Benefit product. Either way you choose, you won't go wrong!

I will however, leave you with one warning about ALL primers: you HAVE to wash your face and remove your makeup before you go to bed if you're using a primer. By its nature, its supposed to block your pores, so lack of makeup removal will result in zits!!!

Do you use makeup primers? What's your favorite brand?


beautyfoodie said...

I use Laura Geller Spackle and Smashbox. I prefer Spackle bc of the name (duh) and the shimmer in the bronze tint. It makes you a little glowy in the best way.

CLEshopaholic said...

Oooh! I will have to try the Spackle! Do you use it in the summmer too? I'm concerned about looking too "glory".

Modern Musings said...

Good to hear. I got the Spackle in my Oct Birchbox and haven't tried it yet. I love Smashbox but everything in their line gives me little superficial bumps. (no matter how well I wash my face) Thanks for the update!

All Lacquered Up said...

I love me some primers and the Smashbox ones are my faves, especially the green one to combat redness, however a lot of people have issues with it because of the silicone so I suggest checking out the Stila one step primer. It's fantastic and water based so pore clogging isn't a problem. Also Laura Mercier radiance primer is awesome of you want to add a subtle glow.

CLEshopaholic said...

ALU- those are great tips! I had no idea about the silicone - it explains the texture! There's actually a new smashbox primer/foundation in one that I want to try!

Also, my summer concern is too "glowy" not "glory". LOL.

Allison M. said...

so I use a eyemakeup primer - Urban Decay - a little shimmery gold but I don't actually wear foundation.

I use MAC powder then sweep some bronzer over it.